In an earlier article, I explained how many of our expectations are actually unhealthy defensive mechanisms that “protect” us from a sense of helplessness, uncertainty, or a more general lack of control.
Of course, unrealistic expectations don’t really protect us. The temporary illusion of control an expectation brings often comes at a steep price—many cases of anxiety, depression, or relationship conflict are the result of unexamined and unhelpful expectations.
A simple example:
- Most people who struggle with chronic anxiety have an expectation that they should be able to control their anxiety.
- While the belief that you can control your anxiety feels good in the short term, you won’t actually succeed at it because anxiety, like all other emotions, can’t be controlled directly.
- As a result, you’re likely to feel even worse: feeling anxious about feeling anxious, or ashamed for feeling anxious.
If you struggle with excessive or unhealthy expectations in your life, taking even a little bit of time to reflect on those expectations can yield pretty incredible results in terms of your relationships, mood, and wellbeing generally.
So try to be on the lookout for the expectations you hold. Anytime you have an interpersonal conflict, for example, there’s a good chance some expectations are at play.
And once you notice a few of them, use the following questions to reflect on them.
1. Is it relevant?
Many expectations came into being years ago—perhaps when you were a child—and have never really been examined or updated since. Which means their relevance for you and your current life could be questionable…
- I had a client once who’s struggled with being overly passive in social situations. She frequently wished she had more confidence to speak up and express her opinions but often got anxious and held back instead.
- After a while, she realized that the real reason she got so anxious and held herself back was because of an expectation she’d had since she was a young girl: If I speak up, I’ll probably get made fun of.
- As a child, she stuttered and her classmates in school would sometimes make fun of her. So at one point, this expectation was at least relevant to her life.
- Now, as a successful 40-year-old professional, she had long since overcome her stuttering issues. And when she did speak up, was never made fun of. But because she had never really examined that old expectation, it just continued to run in her brain, influencing her moods and emotions, her behavior and choices, and even her self-esteem.
When you’ve identified an expectation you hold, it’s worth asking how relevant that expectation is to your life currently. Because a surprising number of our expectations were established in one set of circumstances and have little if any relevance to our current circumstances. And the more you can show yourself how irrelevant an expectation is, the less likely you are to be negatively affected by it.
2. Is it realistic?
Now, some expectations are perfectly relevant but also unrealistic. And this can end up having the same negative effects.
- Maybe you have an expectation that people should be reasonable. Well, that’s very relevant because you most likely have to interact with people on a regular basis. And the result of those interactions often depends on how reasonable the person is.
- Let’s say you tell your partner that it’s important to be on time for dinner with friends tonight. Later in the day, you start worrying that they’ll be late (as they often are). But then your expectation kicks in: people should be reasonable… they’ll be on time.
- Dinner time comes and your partner’s running late as usual. Because your expectation that your partner will be reasonable has been violated, you start to ruminate on other situations in the past when they’ve done the same thing. After just a few minutes of this, you’re incredibly irritated and end up not having a very good time at dinner because you’re stuck dwelling on how unreasonable and disrespectful your partner is because they can’t just be on time for things.
In this example, it’s perfectly understandable that you would get upset at your partner for being late. But the key thing to see is that your expectation that they will be reasonable and make dinner on time isn’t very realistic or likely given their past behavior.
Of course, in the moment, that expectation helped soothe your anxiety about the very real possibility that they would be late. But in the end, you ended up not only irritated that they were late for dinner, but fairly consumed by it… Not only was your anger much stronger and longer lasting than it would have been otherwise, but you also didn’t really get to enjoy an evening with your friends.
Right or wrong, relevant or not, if your expectations are unrealistic, you’re setting yourself up for chronic frustration, disappointment, and ultimately, resentment.
So when you’ve identified an expectation—especially an expectation of another person—ask yourself how realistic it is given what you know about them. Think back on how they’ve behaved or acted in the past. Then try your best to separate what you would like to be the case from what is likely to be the case and revise your expectations to be in line with the latter.
3. Is it helpful?
Expectations are always doing something—exerting some kind of force or effect on us. So it’s worth asking: On net, are my expectations helping me or hurting me?
Often, we convince ourselves that an expectation is necessary or unavoidable simply because it’s true. But as we’ll see, that’s not always a very healthy expectation…
- Maybe you have the expectation that People should be polite to waiters. If you asked 100 people whether that was true, you’d probably get at least 98 of them to agree with you that, yes, people should be polite to their waiters. But, even if it is true that people should be polite to waiters, is that expectation helping you?
- You personally will likely be polite to waiters regardless. And your expectation that everyone should be polite to waiters has zero effect on whether that jerk across the restaurant will end up being polite to his waiter.
- But because of this expectation that plays in your head every time you go out to eat, you get frustrated and upset when you see people not being polite to their waiters. And aside from feeling upset, it also distracts you from your meal, the person you’re eating with, etc.
- So this expectation has some very real and predictable downsides with virtually no upside
- In other words, when it comes to expectations: Just because it’s true doesn’t make it helpful.
Now, it’s often difficult to let go of these types of expectations because it somehow just feels wrong.
The key here is to see that giving up your expectation that what’s true doesn’t mean you’re invalidating the truth of it. It’s perfectly possible to believe that people should be polite to waiters without expecting that they will.
What’s more, letting go of that expectation doesn’t even mean you can’t act on that belief if you need to. If someone’s being borderline abusive to a waiter, you might well make the decision to intervene. But that has nothing to do with your expectations.
Remember, expectations are always doing something. And quite often what they do is intensify and prolong difficult emotions without making any sort of positive change in you or the world.
So why hold on to them?
So should we just not have any expectations at all?
I won’t necessarily go that far.
There are probably situations where expectations can be a positive force in your life—especially if they meet the criteria of being relevant, realistic, and helpful.
But because expectations so easily devolve into unhealthy defense mechanisms, it’s essential to be aware of the expectations you hold and how they impact you.
To that end, I’ll leave you with a puzzler…
Maybe the best expectation is expecting that our expectations aren’t very helpful?
A little healthy skepticism is a great way to stay reflective and intentional about our expectations instead of taking them for granted.